Discussions on the death penalty

Malaysia – Last Thursday, the Cabinet resolved to abolish the death sentence. This doesn’t mean the death sentence is gone; judges will soon be empowered to impose an alternate punishment.

Anyway, a Facebook survey revealed some fascinating correlations.

First, the death sentence is seen as “barbaric” and without redeeming features.

Its finality and terminal status give closure that many don’t like.

It’s encouraging to know that a feeling of life’s sanctity continues in society, even if this life has done something terrible.

Some of my friends say nobody and no court can judge whether a criminal’s life may be justifiedly lost.

This combines with another argument against the death sentence, because it’s retributive.

Death penalty is ridiculous. Dick wants Tom (and his family) dead for killing his parents. That’s it . No reconciliation, no forgiveness.

Related Posts

Death punishment is about retribution, not justice.

What is Justice? Who decides?

How can we judge whether a life should be taken as a penalty? Who decides whether a murderer deserves the death penalty?

Is the death penalty’s opposition cultural? Is it “progressive” to sentence a serial murderer to 200 years vs. the electric chair? Why?

I know liberals who support death punishment. Paedophilia and repeated rape are considered death sentences.

These same folks often say murderers should be spared the gallows. When children are harmed, sanctions like chemical castration and/or jail don’t work.

How much does culture influence our opposition to the death penalty? How can we avoid subjective perspectives on the degree or “category” of damage warranting death? How can we judge whether child abuse is worse than narcotics?

The greatest proponents of the death sentence argue that a criminal chooses his own destiny by committing crimes that lead to it.

Murder is the clearest example. It’s “simple” to criticize the death sentence for drugs.

The recent execution of a mentally challenged Malaysian for drug trafficking may seem excessive.

If I kill someone, shouldn’t I be killed in return? Anything less than justice? While I loathe to support such a viewpoint, I must say (and am pleased) that neither I nor my family have been victims of a particularly horrible crime. I can’t speak for the victims’ families.

Calls to abolish the death penalty may be disrespectful if done too hastily.

Do we consider what victims’ families want? If it’s not our family that’s been hurt by a murderer, do we have the right to suppress the victims’ families’ calls for the criminal’s death?

This subject may take additional thinking.

* This is only a Columnist’s viewpoint.

Katherine S

1/4 German, 3/4 Malaysian. I write, follow and monitor closely political news happening in Malaysia, and other happening news in the ASEAN region. Newswriter for the best ASEAN news website - The Asian Affairs.

Recent Posts

Vietnam International Defense Expo 2024

The 2024 Vietnam International Defense Expo was inaugurated by the Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh on December 19, 2024 and…

December 22, 2024

Shooting concludes: Stranger Things 5 to release on Netflix in 2025

Created by the Duffer Brothers, Stranger Things is one of the most popular sci-fi horror series globally. It is set…

December 21, 2024

China’s Hypersonic Expansion in Asia Raises Alarms for India

According to the US Department of Defense, China has now produced the most sophisticated supply of hypersonic weapons in the…

December 21, 2024

Melaka International Halal Festival 2024

The Melaka International Halal Festival 2024 aims to turn the city as the prime center of the Halal products and…

December 21, 2024

Chunichi Dragons Renews the Contract of Hiroto Takahashi with Annual Salary of 120 million yen

On Saturday, the stalwart of Chunichi Dragons Pitcher, Hiroto Takahashi attended the negotiation for his contract renewal for the next…

December 21, 2024

Biden-Harris administration cancels another $4.28 billion in US student loans

US President Joe Biden has cancelled another $4.28 billion in student loans for nearly 55,000 people across the country, the…

December 20, 2024

This website uses cookies.

Read More